The theory of comparative advantage, first developed by english economist david ricardo in 1817, is a theory about the potential gains from trade for companies, countries or people that arise on account of differences in factor endowments or technological progress. Comparative advantage is what determines whether it pays to produce a good or import it. An economist who has not thought about the issue might stare blankly if confronted with the question. Study questions with answers lecture 3 comparative advantage and the gains from trade part 1. Samuelson named ricardos law of comparative advantage. A brief history of the concept of comparative advantage. In 1930 gottfried haberler detached the doctrine of comparative advantage from ricardo s labor theory of value and provided a modern opportunitycost formulation. A country will specialise in that line of production in which it has a greater relative or comparative advantage in costs than other countries and will depend upon imports from abroad of all such commodities in which it has relative cost disadvantage. Comparative advantage defying development strategy and cross country poverty incidence abu bakkar siddique kdi school of public policy and management, korea this paper argues that poverty in a country is endogenously determined by the countrys longterm economic development strategy. David ricardos discovery of comparative advantage university of. The theory of absolute cost advantage and the theory of comparative cost advantage both led the foundations for the modern theory of trade. Ricardos theory of international trade a critique of.
Using tools from the mathematics of complementarity, this paper offers a simple yet unifying perspective on the fundamental forces that shape comparative advantage. The classical approach, in terms of comparative cost advantage, as presented by ricardo, basically seeks to explain. The theory of comparative advantage suggests that a person can have a comparative advantage at producing something if he or she can produce it at a lower cost than anyone else. If each country now specializes in one producing good then assuming constant returns to scale, the output will double. As we say in economics, it depends and its all relative 2. Jan 06, 2015 the theory of comparative advantage, first developed by english economist david ricardo in 1817, is a theory about the potential gains from trade for companies, countries or people that arise on account of differences in factor endowments or technological progress.
It might be very be wrong to use comparative advantages to decide economy of a country. Study questions with answers university of michigan. Absolute and comparative advantage o the us produces some bananas for domestic consumption, but not enough to satisfy total demand for bananas. Definition of comparative advantage economics help. David ricardo vs adam smith why do countries trade. The chapter examines the historical process of how the comparative advantage theory developed from james and john stuart mill to the modern theory, by. Free trade and absolute and comparative advantage publish. Another englishman, colonel robert torrens, included a brief, very rough formulation of the law of comparative advantage in one paragraph in an essay on the external corn trade 1815, but ricardos.
This chapter presents the first formal model of international trade. Therefore the uk has a comparative advantage in producing books because it has a lower opportunity cost of 0. Pdf david ricardos discovery of comparative advantage. Pdf the theory of comparative advantage how applicable is. It differs from the latter in terms of the definition of the four. The ricardo effect served as a red herring to cause scholars to possibly misread. Jul 14, 2019 david ricardo 17721823 was a classical british economist best known for his theory on wages and profit, labor theory of value, theory of comparative advantage, and theory of rents.
Also, the comparative advantage theory fails to acknowledge transportation costs. Assume that there are only two goods, cars and computers, and one productive resource which is some composite of land, labor, and capital. David ricardo, working in the early part of the 19th century, realised that absolute advantage was a limited case of a more general theory. The theory of comparative advantage became the rationale for free trade agreements. First, since there is no international currency, we must deal with the problem of exchange rates. Truth, however, in samuelsons reply refers to the fact that ricardo s theory of comparative advantage is mathematically correct, not that it is empirically valid. This theory, which was developed by the renowned economist david ricardo, illustrates that specialization and trade benefit both parties in the exchange and generate wealth. Theory of comparative cost by david ricardo definition and. The theory of comparative advantages the main conclusion of the theory of comparative advantages is that countries can gain always from trade because what matters are comparative advantages and not absolute advantages. Ricardos numerical example versus ricardian trade model. Absolute advantage and comparative advantage are two concepts in economics and international trade. Mar 12, 20 it is mostly reliant on the law of comparative advantage, which as i shall discuss, has some very significant flaws.
Comparative advantage, economic theory, first developed by 19thcentury british economist david ricardo, that attributed the cause and benefits of international trade to the differences in the relative opportunity costs costs in terms of other goods given up of producing the same commodities among countries. The latter tries to reconstruct ricardos theory with neoclassical tools and. As the world bank suggests, this way a country can acquire comparative advantage. It is one of the simplest models, and still, by introducing the principle of comparative advantage, it offers some of the most compelling reasons supporting international trade.
Mar 16, 2014 diana dinh san jose state university bus 187 global dimensions of business, section 11 dr. David ricardo believed that the international trade is governed by the comparative cost advantage rather than the absolute cost advantage. The classical theory of the international trade, also known as the theory of comparative costs, was first formulated by ricardo, and later improved by john stuart mill, cairnes, and bastable. The ricardo effect served as a red herring to cause scholars to possibly misread ricardos letters in a crucial period. He, therefore, regards the theory of comparative advantage as cumbersome, unrealistic, and as a clumsy and dangerous tool of analysis. Understand the essentials of the theory of comparative advantage also known as the law of comparative advantage or the law of relative advantage in just 50 minutes with this practical and concise book. David ricardos theory of comparative advantage comparative. The classical theory of international trade is popularly known as the theory of comparative costs or advantage. Chapter 2 the ricardian theory of comparative advantage. It is based on the neoclassical formulation of the theory of comparative advantage. Ruffin1 abstract this paper argues that ricardos discovery of the law of comparative advantage probably occurred in october 1816.
What are the advantages and disadvantages of comparative. Structural transformation and patterns of comparative advantage in the product space ricardo hausmann and bailey klinger abstract in this paper we examine the product space and its consequences for the process of structural transformation. In effect, the theory of international trade followed the perceived. Apr 19, 2017 that is, ricardo on trade and comparative advantage might be 200 years old today but its all still entirely relevant.
The term comparative means relative not necessarily absolute. Comparative advantage exists when a country has a margin of superiority in the production of a good or service i. Absolute and comparative advantagethe theory of comparative advantageextensions and limits comparative advantage a country is said to have a comparative advantage in the production of one good if its opportunity cost is lower than in any other country trade between any two countries is paretooptimal if each. Old idea, new evidence arnaud costinot, dave donaldson. This paper argues that ricardo s discovery of the law of comparative advantage probably occurred in october 1816. There are some special features of international trade so we need a separate explanation. International trade and investment program when asked to name one proposition in the social sciences that is both true and nontrivial, paul samuelson famously replied. The goal of this paper is to assess the empirical performance of ricardo s ideas. How does comparative advantage differ from absolute advantage. Unifying ricardos theories of growth and comparative advantage. Multiple choice select the best answer of those given. And thus, of course, we really should get to grips with the only logically.
Ricardo may not have been the first economist to advance the concept of comparative advantage. Absolute and comparative advantages smith and ricardo. His works and writings were collected in ricardo, david 1981. Before this is done, a short introduction to the theory is given, which is closely linked to the name david ricardo,2 who formulates it in chapter 7 of his main work on the principles of political economy and. He argued that it made no sense to restrict lowcost and highquality wheat from countries with the right climate and soil conditions. The theory of comparative advantage was first devised by david ricardo in 1817 and is so popular it is often considered a law even though economics as a social science has no laws. David ricardos comparative advantage and developing countries. The works and correspondence of david ricardo 1st paperback ed. The theory is most closely associ ated with the writings of the great english clas sical school economist. Pass the port david ricardos comparative advantage is 200. David ricardo is best known today for his pioneering articulation of the theory of comparative advantage the idea that trade is most mutually.
What is the relationship between comparative advantage and gains from trade. Ricardo, improving upon adam smiths exposition, developed the theory of international trade based on what is known as the principle of comparative advantage cost. If one country has a comparative advantage over another country with some good, then even if that other country has an absolute advantage, it is advantageous to both countries for the country with the comparative advantage to export the good to the other country. David ricardos discovery of comparative advantage roy j. It also clearly laid out the theory of comparative advantage, which argued that all nations could benefit from free trade, even if a nation was less efficient at producing all kinds of goods than its trading partners.
Absolute and comparative advantage to trade or not to trade, that is the question. As a successful classical economist of the 1700 to 1800s, david ricardo is known for many of his contributions to political and classical economics including the theory of comparative advantage. Ricardo s discovery of the law of comparative advantage must rank as one of the more remarkable stories in the history of economic thought. According to the theory of comparative advantage, which of the following is not a reason why countries trade. Comparative advantage if a country or individual is relatively more e. When asked to name one proposition in the social sciences that is both true and nontrivial, paul samuelson famously replied. Hollander 1911 clearly documents that torrens recanted. Deconstructing the theory of comparative advantage world social. Luck, genius, a desire to contribute to political economy, and two weeks of intense thought united in a super rich stock jobber to give economics one of its most fundamental laws.
David ricardos theory of comparative cost advantage. Theory of comparative advantage of international trade. An elementary theory of comparative advantage by arnaud costinot1 comparative advantage, whether driven by technology or factor endowment, is at the core of neoclassical trade theory. The socalled ricardian trade model of contemporary economic textbooks is not a rational reconstruction of ricardo s famous numerical example in chapter seven of the principles. A fine example is how india has managed to acquire a comparative advantage in it because of huge investments in education and technology. When asked to name one proposition in the social sciences that is both true and nontrivial, paul s. The concept of comparative advantages argues that even if a country doesnt have an absolute advantage, it should trade and specialize in the production of a product for which it has a comparative advantage, which means a lower relative price. Pdf ricardos numerical example versus ricardian trade. As an alternative, ohlin has propounded a new theory which is known as the modern theory of international trade.
Unlike the neoclassical economists, david ricardo based his arguments on the labour theory of value. Challenging economics theory of comparative advantage. The history of david ricardo and his ideals for the future including the ricardian model. The importance of the ricardian theory of international. International trade involves the extension of the principle of specialisation or division labour to the sphere of international exchange. Ricardos theory is broadly regarded as one of the most powerful yet counterintuitive insights in economics, hence, the theory implies that comparative advantage rather than absolute advantage. Comparative advantage is an economic law referring to the ability of any given economic actor to produce goods and services at a lower opportunity cost than other economic actors. Ricardo noted portugal could produce both wine and cloth with less labour than england. Comparative advantage and trade in services brian hindley and alasdair smith oes the theory of comparative advantage, developed over two centuries to clarify thought about trade in goods, apply to trade in services. Granular comparative advantage princeton university. Ricardo s law of comparative advantage can now be formulated as follows. The volume of trade is shown by the shaded triangles. Students first encounter ricardo when beingtold how the political case for free trade experienced a mighty advance as his theory of comparative advantage replaced smiths theory of absolute advantage. Ricardo used in his model just two countries and two goods, however, and so.
This paper is based on an invited lecture, the author held at the university of applied sciences stralsund in may 2015. Smiths argument about absolute advantage was refined and developed by david ricardo in 1817. A country will specialise in that line of production in which it has a greater relative or comparative advantage in costs than other countries and will depend upon imports from abroad of all such commodities in which it has relative cost. Truth, however, in samuelsons reply refers to the fact that ricardos theory of comparative advantage is mathematically correct, not that it is empirically valid.
David ricardos theory of comparative advantage free download as powerpoint presentation. To bring ricardos ideas to the data, one must overcome a key empirical challenge. Direct and indirect critiques oumar bouare aem following smiths advocacy of free trade and competition, david ricardo attempts to strengthen his theory of absolute advantage, which excludes from international trade countries. Jan 20, 2020 therefore the uk has a comparative advantage in producing books because it has a lower opportunity cost of 0. Haberlers reformulation of comparative advantage revolutionized the theory of international trade and laid the conceptual groundwork of modern trade theories. The theory of comparative advantage a country has a comparative advantage when it can produce a good at a lower opportunity cost than another country. Old idea, new evidence by arnaud costinot and dave donaldson. Comparative advantage was first described by david ricardo in his 1817 book on the principles of political economy and taxation he used an example involving england and portugal.
Free trade is based on the theory of comparative advantage. Comparative advantage, economic structure and growth. This paper intends to critically analyse the theoretical and. Solved question 1 explain david ricardos theory of. Historicising ricardos comparative advantage theory. It can be seen that portugal can produce both wheat and wine more cheaply than england ie it has an absolute advantage in both commodities. Comparative advantage comparative advantage the theory of comparative advantage david ricardo developed the theory. In this report many aspects of the comparative advantage theory were discussed, what the comparative advantage theory is in regards to opportunity costs and internationalfree trade, as well as who benefits from the theory and what effects it has on canada. Absolute advantage refers to the uncontested superiority of a country or business to produce a. Ricardo developed his approach to combat trade restrictions on imported wheat in england. Your response should be at least 500 words in length. Ricardo s numerical example versus ricardian trade model. Ricardos law of comparative advantage a divided world. Question 1 explain david ricardo s theory of comparative advantage.
252 1451 566 950 357 977 723 1029 961 848 360 1060 79 1273 1244 1305 481 795 1550 784 720 46 688 1076 330 716 1112 97 27 17 727 838 3 819 900 430 142 707 21 1092 362